The Servant Girl Annihilator: Austin’s Forgotten Nightmare

The Dark Beneath: Scary Folklore & Whispers in Texas

CASE FILE #12

Austin, 1885. The air was thick with heat and secrets. By day, the city bustled with carriages and commerce. By night, it belonged to something else—something that moved without sound, struck without mercy, and vanished without a trace.

They called him The Servant Girl Annihilator. But names are powerless against monsters.

It began with Mollie. She was found in the backyard, her body torn apart, her head nearly severed. Her lover, Walter, was inside—barely conscious, bleeding, confused. He remembered nothing. The door was locked. The window was open. The killer had come and gone like smoke.

Then came Eliza. Then Irene. Then Mary. Each woman taken from her bed in the dead of night. Each dragged outside. Each mutilated. The killer left no footprints. No fingerprints. Just blood. And silence.

The city panicked. Families nailed their windows shut. Men took turns standing guard. But it didn’t matter. The killer was always one step ahead. He moved like a shadow, striking with surgical precision. He didn’t just kill—he performed. Some victims were found with sharp objects inserted into their ears. Others were posed like offerings. It was ritual. It was rage. It was something ancient.

Then came December. Two women—Susan and Eula—murdered on the same night. Susan was found in her garden, her skull crushed, her body arranged like a sacrificial altar. Eula was discovered in an alley, her head split open, her nightgown soaked in blood. Her husband, James, was arrested. But the city knew better. This wasn’t domestic. This was something else.

Theories swirled. A madman. A butcher. A doctor. A demon. One psychic claimed the killer was possessed by a spirit older than Texas itself. Another said he was a traveler—someone who fed on fear and moved from town to town, leaving only blood behind.

And then… it stopped.

No more murders. No more blood. The killer vanished. Some believe he fled to London and became Jack the Ripper. Others think he died in Austin, buried in an unmarked grave beneath the city he defiled. But the fear he carved into Austin’s bones? That never left.

Today, the old neighborhoods still stand. Victorian homes with creaking porches and shuttered windows. Locals say if you walk past the corner of Pecan and Sabine after midnight, you’ll hear footsteps. A whisper. A creak. Some swear they’ve seen a man in a long coat, standing in the shadows, watching.

The Servant Girl Annihilator was never caught. Never named. But his legend lives on—in the dust, in the dark, and in the silence between footsteps.

If CASE FILE #12 is the first you're reading, make sure to go back and check out "The Dark Beneath" series of posts! The Dark Beneath: Scary Folklore & Whispers in Texas

Until the next body drops,

Loretta & David Allseitz

"Unmasking evil, one body at a time"